You line your waterline at 8 a.m., and by lunch there's a black smear under your eye and a raccoon staring back from the bathroom mirror. The waterline is wet, so most pencils slide right off it. If you're hunting for the best eyeliner for waterline wear, here are the 5 best in 2026, ranked by rating and review count. We didn't test them ourselves. We read the listings and the reviews, and noted what buyers say about smudging, stinging and wear time. Every pick here costs under about $10, so you can try a couple without much risk.


What to Look For in an Eyeliner for the Waterline

Waterproof and smudge-proof. This matters more on the waterline than anywhere else, because tears and natural moisture break down regular pencils fast. Look for words like waterproof, 16-hour or 24-hour wear on the listing.

Creamy but not greasy. A soft gel pencil glides without tugging your lid. A formula that's too oily will migrate, so a bit of grip is what you want.

Retractable or twist-up. No sharpener, no shavings near your eyes, and the tip stays fresh. The downside is you can't get a razor-fine point, but you don't need one on the waterline.

Eye safety. Check that the liner is ophthalmologist tested, and say so if you wear contacts. If your eyes water easily or sting, see our hypoallergenic eyeliner picks.

Shade. Black makes eyes look sharper and more defined. Brown is softer and works well for everyday looks. If you want a lighter, eye-opening effect, try our nude eyeliner list.


The 5 Best Eyeliners for the Waterline in 2026

1. NYX Professional Makeup Vivid Rich Mechanical Eye Pencil (Always Onyx)

Best for: a rich black liner that comes in lots of shades.

Check Price On Amazon

This is a retractable, creamy pencil with a lot of pigment in one swipe. It has the best score on the list, with a 4.3 rating from more than 100,000 reviews. The line comes in a long list of shades, including metallics and colors.

What makes it stand out: It's built for lining the lash line and the waterline, and you don't need a sharpener. The black goes on dark in one pass.

Good to know: Some reviewers say it can fade or smudge on very watery eyes, so set it with a little matching powder if you tend to tear up. Check which shade you're picking on the listing.

2. wet n wild Mega Last Breakup-Proof Retractable Gel Eyeliner

Best for: the lowest price and long wear on a budget.

Check Price On Amazon

A black retractable gel pencil with an ultra-fine tip, rated 4.5 stars by more than 40,000 buyers. The brand says it lasts up to 16 hours and it's waterproof, vegan and cruelty-free.

What makes it stand out: It's often the cheapest option here, at around $2 to $3. The thin tip lets you draw a neat line close to the lashes.

Good to know: The shade options are limited compared with NYX, and it's a thin line, so it's not the one for a bold, smoky look.

3. Rimmel Scandaleyes Waterproof Gel Pencil Eyeliner

Best for: a smooth, long-wearing gel pencil with a soft feel.

Check Price On Amazon

This is a 0.04 oz waterproof gel pencil in black, rated 4.5 stars from almost 37,000 reviews. The brand calls it smudge-proof and ultra smooth, and it costs about $5.

What makes it stand out: The gel is soft and glides without pulling. It's made for the lash line and the waterline, and it comes in a few shades.

Good to know: It's a regular pencil, not a twist-up, so you'll need to sharpen it. Press lightly, because a soft pencil can get messy if you overdo it.

4. Maybelline Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Eyeliner (Espresso)

Best for: a softer brown liner with up to 24-hour wear.

Check Price On Amazon

A twist-up, waterproof pencil in Espresso brown that the brand says lasts up to 24 hours. It has a 4.6 rating from more than 27,000 reviews, the highest rating on the list, and costs around $8.

What makes it stand out: Brown is gentler than black, so it suits everyday wear and lighter skin tones or eyes. It glides on easily and needs no sharpening.

Good to know: This listing is the Espresso shade. If you want black or another shade, check the options on the page before you buy.

5. Rimmel Exaggerate Auto Waterproof Eye Definer (Blackest Black, 2-Pack)

Best for: a twist-up black liner with a built-in smudger, in a 2-pack.

Check Price On Amazon

This listing has two retractable, waterproof black pencils for about $11. It has a 4.5 rating from around 4,300 reviews, fewer than the others, which is why it ranks last.

What makes it stand out: It's a creamy, high-pigment liner that works on the lash line and the waterline. The 2-pack gives you a spare.

Good to know: The smudger tip is handy for smoky looks but can pick up product, so keep it clean. Reviews are fewer, so it's a less proven pick than the others.


How to Apply Eyeliner on Your Waterline

  1. Start with clean, dry eyes. Pat the waterline with a tissue so the liner has something to grip.
  2. Look up slightly and gently pull your lower lid down. Draw a short line, or press the tip along the inner rim in small strokes.
  3. Don't press hard. Light pressure prevents stinging and lessens smudging.
  4. Let it set for a few seconds before you blink. Wait for it to dry first, then add mascara.
  5. At night, use an oil-based or waterproof eye makeup remover on a cotton pad. Hold it on your closed lid for a few seconds, then wipe gently.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you get eyeliner to stay on your waterline?

Dry the waterline first, use a waterproof gel or mechanical pencil, and apply with light pressure. Eyeshadow primer on the lids and a little matching powder over the liner can also help. Let it set before you blink.

What is the best eyeliner for the waterline that doesn't smudge?

Based on ratings and reviews, the waterproof gel pencils here are your best bet: NYX Vivid Rich, wet n wild Mega Last and Rimmel Scandaleyes. None can promise zero smudging on watery eyes.

What is the best eyeliner for the waterline for sensitive eyes?

Look for ophthalmologist-tested liners, fragrance-free formulas and a soft pencil that doesn't tug. Do a quick test on your hand first and stop if your eyes sting. If you have a medical eye condition, ask your eye doctor.

What color eyeliner looks best on the waterline?

Black makes eyes look more defined. Brown is softer and good for everyday looks. White or nude liner can make eyes look wider and more awake.

How do you remove waterproof eyeliner?

Use an oil-based or waterproof eye makeup remover. Soak a cotton pad, hold it on your closed eye for a few seconds to dissolve the liner, then wipe gently. Don't scrub.

Keep Reading

Final Thoughts

For most people, we'd start with the NYX Vivid Rich pencil. It has the best score here and comes in plenty of shades. If you want the cheapest option that still gets great reviews, the wet n wild Mega Last is hard to beat.

Pick the Rimmel Scandaleyes for a soft, creamy gel, and the Maybelline Unstoppable if you prefer brown and want a twist-up pencil. If your eyes water a lot, expect some smudging with any of these, and set the liner with a little powder.


Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Here's how we pick products.