You put on a coat of mascara in the morning, and by noon it's either clumped, flaking or sitting in smudges under your eyes. Maybelline has a lot of mascaras, and the names (Sky High, Lash Sensational, Falsies, Colossal) don't tell you which one does what.
This guide is for anyone who wants a drugstore mascara that works and doesn't cost much. Here are the 5 best Maybelline mascaras in 2026, ranked by rating and review count, with the look each gives you and the catch. We didn't test them ourselves. We went through the listings and what reviewers say. Every one of these is the washable formula, not waterproof.
What to Look For in a Maybelline Mascara
Length or volume. Sky High is the length pick. Colossal and Great Lash lean toward volume. Lash Sensational and Falsies sit in the middle and fan or lift.
The brush. The brush shape does most of the work. A flexible tower brush reaches the corners, a curved brush fans out, and a mini brush gives you more control on short lashes.
Washable vs waterproof. All five here are washable, so they come off with warm water and won't survive a swim or a good cry. If you need waterproof, check the tube before you buy.
Sensitive eyes. Maybelline says Sky High and Lash Sensational are ophthalmologist tested, and Sky High is also allergy tested and fine for contact lens wearers. If you need more, see our hypoallergenic eyeliner picks.
Shade. Most listings are for black, but some are "blackest black," which is darker than a plain black. Double-check the shade in the title.
The 5 Best Maybelline Mascaras in 2026
1. Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Washable Mascara
Best for: long, lifted lashes that still feel light.
The mascara that's all over social media. It has a bendy Flex Tower brush and a formula with bamboo extract and fibers, built to add length from root to tip.
What makes it stand out: It's the most reviewed Maybelline mascara by a long way, with more than 190,000 reviews at 4.5 stars. Maybelline says it's ophthalmologist and allergy tested and suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
Good to know: It adds length more than thickness, so it's not the one for a dramatic, thick look. It's washable, so it will smudge in rain or tears.
2. Maybelline Lash Sensational Full Fan Effect Washable Mascara
Best for: full, separated lashes with a fanned-out look.
A mascara with a curved brush that has ten layers of bristles, so it can reach the roots and fan the lashes out. It comes in blackest black.
What makes it stand out: It has over 119,000 reviews at 4.5 stars. It builds from natural to dramatic, and the brush is good at separating lashes. Maybelline says it's ophthalmologist tested and contact lens safe.
Good to know: The curved brush takes a few tries to get used to, especially on the lower lashes. It can clump if you pile on too many coats.
3. Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara
Best for: a classic, everyday volume mascara that's easy on the budget.
The pink-and-green tube you've seen for decades. Maybelline describes the formula as lash-doubling, and says it conditions as it thickens. It has a small brush for control.
What makes it stand out: It's the cheapest of the five and holds a 4.5 rating from more than 56,000 reviews. The small brush is easier to use on short lashes and the bottom row.
Good to know: It's a simple formula, so it won't give you extreme length. If you want drama, step up to Sky High or Falsies.
4. Maybelline Volum' Express The Colossal Washable Mascara
Best for: big, bold volume with a classic look.
The yellow tube with a mega brush and a collagen-infused formula. This listing is Glam Black, which is a little softer than blackest black.
What makes it stand out: It's the volume pick, and it's easy to find in drugstores too. It has a 4.5 rating from almost 23,000 reviews.
Good to know: It has the fewest reviews of the 4.5-star group, and the big brush can leave clumps if you don't wipe it off first.
5. Maybelline The Falsies Lash Lift Washable Mascara
Best for: lifted, curled lashes that look like a lash lift.
A mascara with a double-curved brush made to lift and curl. The formula is washable and is built to add volume and length with a lift that lasts all day.
What makes it stand out: The double-curved brush grabs every lash and lifts it, so straight lashes look curled without an eyelash curler.
Good to know: It has the lowest rating of the five at 4.4 stars, and the brush is bulky for tiny lashes. Curl it first if your lashes are very straight.
How to Apply Mascara So It Doesn't Clump
- Curl your lashes first, if you use a curler.
- Wipe the extra off the wand on the tube's rim.
- Start at the root and wiggle the brush up to the tips.
- Add a second coat while the first is still wet, then stop. A third coat is where clumps start.
- Comb through with a clean spoolie while it's damp.
- Replace the tube every three months to avoid eye infections.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best Maybelline mascara for volume?
What is the best Maybelline mascara for length?
What is the best Maybelline mascara for sensitive eyes?
What is the best Maybelline mascara for short lashes?
What is the best waterproof Maybelline mascara?
Keep Reading
Final Thoughts
If you only try one, try Sky High. It has the most reviews by far, a 4.5 rating and the lightest feel. Choose Lash Sensational if you want a fuller, fanned look.
Great Lash is the budget classic and the easiest on short lashes, Colossal is the volume pick, and Falsies Lash Lift is for lashes that need a curl. We didn't test any of them, so check recent reviews for the shade you pick.
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Here's how we pick products.
