You buy a mascara because the label says cruelty free, then find out the brand is owned by a company that sells in markets where animal testing is required. It happens a lot. Here are the 5 best cruelty free mascaras in 2026, all sold on Amazon and ranked by their ratings and review counts. We didn't personally test them. We read the listings and the reviews. We also took a few mascaras out of the old version of this post (two Maybelline and two L'Oreal) because those brands aren't on the major cruelty free lists. If you like a bold look, our e.l.f. mascara guide goes deeper on that brand.

What to Look For in a Cruelty Free Mascara

A real certification. Look for the Leaping Bunny or PETA bunny logo on the box, not just the words "cruelty free." Brands change owners and policies, so check the Leaping Bunny or PETA lists before you buy.

Vegan or not. Cruelty free means no animal testing. Vegan means no animal ingredients. A mascara can be one and not the other, so read the listing if both matter to you.

Waterproof or washable. Waterproof formulas survive tears and humidity but need an oil-based remover. Washable ones come off with warm water and a cleanser.

Brush shape. A thick brush builds volume. A slim or conic brush separates and reaches small corner lashes.

Sensitive eyes. If your eyes water easily, pick a formula that says it is ophthalmologist tested or made for sensitive eyes, and skip fibers.

The 5 Best Cruelty Free Mascaras in 2026

1. essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara, Black

Best for: a drugstore mascara with a false-lash look on a small budget.

Check Price On Amazon

A black mascara with a cone-shaped fiber brush. It is the most reviewed mascara here, with more than 420,000 ratings on Amazon.

What makes it stand out: It scores best on our list, 4.3 stars from over 420,000 reviews. The cone brush is made to separate lashes and add volume, and it sells for just a few dollars.

Good to know: Some reviewers say it can clump if you apply a lot of coats, and it isn''t waterproof. Wipe the wand before you start.

2. Urban Decay Perversion Volumizing Mascara, Intense Black

Best for: people who want a very black, dramatic lash and don''t mind paying more.

Check Price On Amazon

A deep black volumizing mascara with a fluffy, criss-cross brush.

What makes it stand out: The listing describes an ultra-creamy, buildable formula in a pure black pigment and says it is smudge-resistant and flake-free. It has 4.4 stars from about 3,400 reviews.

Good to know: It costs more than a drugstore tube. Urban Decay is a L''Oreal brand, so check the current PETA or Leaping Bunny status if that matters to you.

3. tarte lights, camera, lashes 4-in-1 mascara

Best for: curl and length with a conditioning formula.

Check Price On Amazon

A full-size black mascara with a 360 degree wand. Shorter bristles build volume and longer ones curl.

What makes it stand out: Tarte says it is vegan and cruelty free, smudge-proof and flake-free, with a claimed 35% increase in lash curl. It has 4.4 stars from about 3,000 reviews.

Good to know: It is one of the pricier picks here, and the claims come from the brand, not from us.

4. e.l.f. Lash It Loud Mascara, Black

Best for: bold, fuller lashes on a tight budget.

Check Price On Amazon

A slim copper tube with a silicone-style wand that grips each lash.

What makes it stand out: The listing calls it vegan and cruelty free, with an intensely pigmented formula that adds volume. It has 4.3 stars from over 2,100 reviews at a very low price.

Good to know: This one is not waterproof, so it can smudge in hot or humid weather. e.l.f. also sells a waterproof version.

5. Pacifica Vegan Collagen Fluffy Lash Mascara, Black

Best for: a vegan formula with a soft, fluffy finish.

Check Price On Amazon

A black mascara in a recyclable glass bottle with a 100% vegan wand.

What makes it stand out: The listing says it is vegan and cruelty free, ophthalmologist tested, and safe for contact lens wearers and sensitive eyes. It has 4.2 stars from about 690 reviews.

Good to know: It has the fewest reviews on the list and the lowest rating, and it builds a fluffy look rather than a dramatic one.

How to Apply Mascara for Fuller Lashes

  1. Curl your lashes first, then let the curler sit for a few seconds.
  2. Wipe extra product off the wand on the tube rim.
  3. Set the brush at the base of the lashes and wiggle it as you pull up and out.
  4. Wait a few seconds, then add a second coat if you want more volume.
  5. Use the tip of the wand sideways on the small lashes in the inner corner.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best cruelty free drugstore mascaras?

From this list, essence Lash Princess and e.l.f. Lash It Loud are both low-priced and sold as cruelty free. Check the box for a Leaping Bunny or PETA logo.

What is the best cruelty free mascara for sensitive eyes?

Pacifica Vegan Collagen Fluffy Lash says it is ophthalmologist tested and safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, per its listing. Patch test any new formula.

Is there a cruelty free waterproof mascara?

Yes. e.l.f. sells a waterproof Lash It Loud, and Urban Decay Perversion comes in a waterproof version. Check the listing for the exact tube before you buy.

Are Maybelline and L'Oreal mascaras cruelty free?

We left them out of this guide because those brands aren't on the main cruelty free lists. Check the Leaping Bunny and PETA sites for current status, since policies change.

Keep Reading

Final Thoughts

If you only buy one, make it the essence Lash Princess. It has the best rating-and-review score by a wide margin and costs very little.

Want a darker, more dramatic lash? Try the Urban Decay Perversion. Want curl and conditioning? Go with tarte. The e.l.f. and Pacifica are the budget and vegan picks.

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Here's how we pick products.