Your favorite eyeliner pencil snaps in half the second you stick it in the sharpener, or it turns into a blunt, crumbly nub. A regular office sharpener is too rough for soft cosmetic pencils. A proper eyeliner sharpener gives you a clean point without chewing it up. Here are the 5 best eyeliner sharpeners in 2026, ranked by rating and review count.
We're going by the Amazon listings and what buyers say in the reviews. We didn't test them ourselves. They all cost under $13, so the question is which one fits your pencils.
What to Look For in an Eyeliner Sharpener
Hole sizes. Slim eyeliner pencils and thick jumbo pencils need different holes. A dual sharpener (two holes) covers both. A universal one has a ring you pull out for the bigger size.
Blade. Look for steel blades. A dull blade tears the pencil. If the blades go dull, replace the sharpener.
Shavings catcher. A lid or cup that holds the shavings keeps your makeup bag clean. A small pick helps clear out blocked blades.
Soft or gel pencils. Soft, creamy and gel pencils are the hardest to sharpen. Putting the pencil in the freezer for 10 to 15 minutes first helps it firm up. For pencils that are easy to keep sharp, see our brown eyeliner and vegan eyeliner picks.
Keeping it clean. Wipe the blade with rubbing alcohol now and then, especially if you share it or use it for eye pencils. It's a tool that goes near your eyes. If you have sensitive eyes, our hypoallergenic eyeliner guide may help.
The 5 Best Eyeliner Sharpeners in 2026
1. Revlon Universal Points Makeup Sharpener
Best for: anyone with a mix of pencil sizes.
A small black sharpener with two holes and a removable adapter ring for bigger pencils. The listing says it works on wooden and plastic cosmetic pencils and comes with a safety pick for cleaning the blades. It has 4.7 stars from nearly 27,000 reviews.
What makes it stand out: It handles small, medium and large pencils, and it has a high rating with a huge review count. It lifts open to empty the shavings.
Good to know: It's plastic, and a few reviewers say the blades dull over time. It's a basic one, so replace it when the point starts to tear.
2. e.l.f. Dual-Pencil Sharpener
Best for: a clear-lidded sharpener with a bonus small one for travel.
A dual sharpener with a clear lid that catches shavings, and a pick on top for cleaning. The listing says it includes a bonus small sharpener, and that it's cruelty free and vegan. It has 4.6 stars from nearly 31,000 reviews, the most on this list.
What makes it stand out: It has the most reviews on the list, and the clear lid lets you see when it's full. The bonus small one is handy for a travel bag.
Good to know: The plastic body feels light. It's not made for very thick jumbo pencils, so check the hole sizes.
3. Julep Cosmetic Makeup Pencil Sharpener
Best for: soft and gel pencils, since it uses steel blades in a sleek tube.
A bullet-shaped sharpener with a built-in shavings collector and a pick to clean the blades. The listing says it has German-made steel blades and works on eyeliner, lip liner and brow pencils, wood or plastic, including gel formulas. It has 4.1 stars from nearly 24,000 reviews.
What makes it stand out: It's the one built for gel pencils, and the compact tube slips into a bag. The shavings stay in the collector.
Good to know: It has the lowest rating of the five. It has one hole size, so it won't fit jumbo pencils.
4. Maybelline New York Expert Tools Dual Sharpener
Best for: a cheap, no-fuss sharpener for regular and thick pencils.
A dual sharpener with two sizes and a clear cover over the blades. It's a plain drugstore tool for eye and lip pencils. It has 4.6 stars from nearly 5,900 reviews.
What makes it stand out: It's simple, cheap and comes from a brand you can find in any drugstore. The two sizes cover most pencils.
Good to know: The packaging gives few details, so don't expect extras like a pick. Replace it if the blade gets dull.
5. L'Oreal Paris Infallible Eye Makeup Pencil Sharpener (2-Pack)
Best for: people who want a spare, with slim and jumbo holes.
A pack of two black dual sharpeners. The listing says they're made of premium steel, with a lid to catch the mess and a plastic pick for cleaning. They sharpen both slim and jumbo pencils. It has 4.7 stars from nearly 5,000 reviews.
What makes it stand out: You get two in a pack, so one can stay in your travel bag. It has a high rating with a lid and a pick.
Good to know: The photos show a plain black body, so it's easy to lose in a makeup bag. The reviews are fewer than for the top picks.
How to Sharpen Eyeliner Without Breaking It
- Chill the pencil in the fridge or freezer for 10 to 15 minutes if it's soft.
- Put it in the correct hole and turn the pencil, not the sharpener, with light pressure.
- Stop when you've got a short, fine point. Over-sharpening wastes product.
- Wipe the tip on a tissue to remove loose bits before using it near your eyes.
- Clean the blades with the pick and wipe them with rubbing alcohol now and then.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best eyeliner sharpener?
Can you use a regular pencil sharpener for eyeliner?
How do you sharpen an eyeliner pencil that keeps breaking?
Which sharpener works on gel eyeliner pencils?
Keep Reading
- Best brown eyeliner for soft, everyday definition
- Best vegan eyeliner in pens, gels and pencils
- Best eyeliner for the waterline
Final Thoughts
If you just want one, we'd get the Revlon Universal Points. It has a high rating, a huge number of reviews, and it handles different pencil sizes. If you want a travel spare, the e.l.f. comes with one.
If you use gel pencils, the Julep is the one to get. For a back-up, the L'Oreal two-pack and the Maybelline are cheap and easy to find. Whichever you pick, swap it out when the point starts to tear.
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Here's how we pick products.